aespa’s Giselle And Ningning Accused Of Being “Mean Girls” For Attitude During Recent Live

“It’s giving K-Drama bullies…”

aespa’s Giselle and NingNing have been accused of being “mean girls” after a recent live.

aespa’s Giselle and NingNing | @aerichandesu/Instagram

Recently, NingNing joined Giselle for her birthday live.

giselle invited ningning to her birthday live since she felt awkward doing it alone while the others were busy. halfway through, winter suddenly appeared! and while giselle was explaining where karina was, karina showed up too, even though she had to leave early. my girls 😭🫂 pic.twitter.com/EmAImMhRX3

— 13 ✿ (@uchgaeri) October 30, 2025

A video from the live broadcast is going viral.

lmaoo #fyp #kpop #kpopfyp #aespa #edit

♬ original sound – BAMGYU!!/KANA

During the video, when asked how to deal with periods, Giselle explained, “Omg, I don’t know. It sucks, doesn’t it? But you know it just means you’re connected to the moon. The moon cycle is back.”

While it sparked questions about whether the two idols had periods, due to past confessions that many female stars are so underweight they don’t get monthly periods…

Yet, many fans hit back at the two idols, claiming they had mean girl energy with their comments and attitudes, sparking major backlash.

Fans tried to defend the two, but many seemed confused about why Giselle and NingNing acted that way.